patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Rare Nazi Book Marked 'Secret' Found by Library Staff in La Grange Park

Ursula Stanek, a director at the La Grange Park Public Library, discovered a rare piece of German history in a book marked "secret."

 

OUTSIDE CHICAGO, IL -- Books given to the La Grange Park Public Library for donation get dropped off with regularity. Some are added to the library's collection, others are sold off, and some find their way into the trash.

A trip to the trash bin might have been the case with one particular book if not for Circulation Services Director Ursula Stanek taking a special interest in it this spring.

Stanek, who grew up in Germany and moved to the United States at age 21, noticed something a little different about this book. It was marked, "Geheim!" — the German word for secret.

"People drop off books all the time," Stanek said. "If there's one that's in German it goes to my desk. I didn't realize what it was until I started to look through it."

The book turned out to be a rare Nazi artifact titled 1938-1941: Vier Jahre, Hermann-Göring-Werke. The book describes a four-year Nazi economic plan for a steel-producing industrial site in the town of Salzgitter, Germany, during World War II. According to the library, the book was given away to workers at the steel mill as a Christmas gift.

Also found in between the book's pages was the letterhead of Nazi commander Hermann Göring and an envelope with a return address printed on it.

Want more headlines like this? Sign up for the La Grange Patch newsletter here, or the Western Springs newsletter here. You can follow us on Facebook too. Like La Grange Patch here and Western Springs Patch here.

Stanek said she first thought about selling the book on eBay.

"I thought we could raise some money for the library's benefit," Stanek said. "I wasn't sure what to do with it, but then I thought that something like this—of historical importance—should be for the public."

Stanek went to work trying to find more information about the book, first contacting a museum in Germany.

"It's a piece of German history," Stanek said. "I thought it should go back there."

When no one returned her phone call, she reached out to the Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center in Skokie. But again, her call was not returned.

Finally, she called the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C. Stanek took the book with her to the museum while on a trip to visit her daughter in Washington D.C. in May.

"They recognized the title right away," Stanek said.

The museum actually had already purchased a reproduced copy of the book at one point, but curators there were thrilled to receive an original copy.

Only Known Copy in U.S.

According to Lenore Bell, library director at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Stanek's find is very significant. Bell said that to her knowledge, the book is the only known copy in a U.S. library or museum. Several copies are known to exist in Europe, she said.

The addition of finding the letterhead and the envelope was significant as well for Bell.

"We actually ended up with two artifacts that way," Bell said.

Bell said she couldn't share the valuation of the book, but said that the museum knew it was a rare find because it is from a numbered edition, meaning only so many copies existed in the first place.

"With materials that are so unique... it can be difficult to come up with a general figure," Bell said.

The fact that the material will now be available to researchers is the real value of the book, she said. The book has been entered into the library's database and cataloged. Researchers looking for a window into the past in relation to the company that produced the book, or the economic plan for Nazi Germany, will now be able to view the material and learn from it.

A Library Mystery

How the rare book turned up in La Grange Park is still a mystery to the library staff, Stanek said. No one recalls who dropped off the book, and so far, no one has come forward claiming to be the donor.

Stanek said she's been surprised by all the attention. She said that when she recently attended a cookout at a park near her home, everyone already knew about the book.

"They had read the [news] articles, and I didn't even know there were any," Stanek said.

Stanek said she was just happy that the book found a suitable home and that she was able to recognize its historical significance.

"It was nice to be able to give it to [the museum]," Stanek said. "They were very pleased to get it."

Stanek said the La Grange Park library has a collection of rare books, which patrons sometimes come in to look at, but she knew of nothing else in the library's collection like this.

"It's just a mystery," she said.

And so it may remain.

Related Topics: La Grange Park Library, Nazi Book Found in La Grange Park, and Secret Nazi Book

Cindy Halpern

10:01 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

An elderly Nazi probably passed away. The children probably just took an armful of books to the library without realizing the book was there.
If so, I am glad another Nazi died.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kristine Harley

12:08 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Well, everyone dies! Not all Germans were Nazis, however. More Jews would be dead were it not for the ordinary German citizens and military members who hid them and/or warned them. Just because someone had a piece of Nazi memorabilia does not make that person a Nazi him- or herself!

Comment_arrow

Skeptic Fence

12:15 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

So, you're glad another fellow human being died? How do you know she was a Nazi and wasn't just a resident that escaped Germany during that time, or even a Jew that had that book. Hell, anybody could of had that book. It's sad you assume and are glad that person died cause of "what" they were, not "who" they were. Hatred has to stop and let the past stay there!

Comment_arrow

Lamar Lafong

12:19 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I bet some Nazi's will be glad when you die as well!

Comment_arrow

Ron

12:22 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Cindy that's a huge assumption. And very disturbing that you even borught it up. Comparatively speaking only a handful of people were Nazis. What about Stalin and his entire regime that killed millions more than the Nazis. Who are the spokespeople for these poor murdered souls. Why don't we all move on. There is enough tragedy in our current world today.

Comment_arrow

MYLES DIMAND

12:36 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

YOU WOULD LIKE IT IF THE PAST STAYED IN THE PAST, RIGHT HANS OR WHATEVER YOUR MONIKER IS. BY REMEMBERING THE PAST WE STAY ALERTED TO ALLOWING ANOTHER ADOLPH OR WHOEVER TO EVER BE ABLE TO GET STARTED ON THE HATE GAMES,,,,AND THAT INCLUDES YOU !

Comment_arrow

Terry Ann

12:37 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I grew up with elderly German speaking neighbors in a small town in New York State. The son of one of them died serving in WWII in the US Air Force. Not all German's are Nazis!

Comment_arrow

Larry Anderson

12:50 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

This is also a tip as to people donating valuable family histories, bibles to a library, I ahve bought some very special ancient family bibles where the doner thought it would be preserved. NOT SO! Lost to everyone. HAve a question?!! How could a person report a Nazi criminal found hiding? While in the Philippines about 6 years ago, a friend was looking to buy some properties. There were 3 Nazi homes, flags, etc. as they found a great hiding place. At the gates of the local airport there was a short, about 5 ft. 5" rounded bald figure of a man, he was German and seemed to try to hide anywhere he went. I tried to ask him something, in his heavily accented English he seemed scared and first asked if I were CIA or FBI, then ran into a corner. Heard from some locals that they knew these were some Nazi hideouts but had good money. How would a person find a way to report such suspisions? I had tried to call and look up places but never found anywhere or anyone. Am very curious who these characters were or are. Very well may be dead by now.

Comment_arrow

Larry Anderson

12:50 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

This is also a tip as to people donating valuable family histories, bibles to a library, I ahve bought some very special ancient family bibles where the doner thought it would be preserved. NOT SO! Lost to everyone. HAve a question?!! How could a person report a Nazi criminal found hiding? While in the Philippines about 6 years ago, a friend was looking to buy some properties. There were 3 Nazi homes, flags, etc. as they found a great hiding place. At the gates of the local airport there was a short, about 5 ft. 5" rounded bald figure of a man, he was German and seemed to try to hide anywhere he went. I tried to ask him something, in his heavily accented English he seemed scared and first asked if I were CIA or FBI, then ran into a corner. Heard from some locals that they knew these were some Nazi hideouts but had good money. How would a person find a way to report such suspisions? I had tried to call and look up places but never found anywhere or anyone. Am very curious who these characters were or are. Very well may be dead by now.

Comment_arrow

Wendy

12:52 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

You're a mean one, Mr. Grinch.
You really are a heel.
You're as cuddly as a cactus,
You're as charming as an eel,
Mr. Grinch.
You're a bad banana with a greasy black peel.

Comment_arrow

Wolf Lindh

1:00 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Please educate yourself before making such a remark. Not all Germans were NAZIs. Most likely if he was a NAZI he would not have come into this country legally, and he would have been sought out by Simon Wiesenthal.

Comment_arrow

Watcher

1:00 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Cindy Halpern and your ilk - you just showed how stupid you are.

Comment_arrow

Watcher

1:02 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Dearest Cindy Halpern - Thank you for showing everyone how stupid you are.

Comment_arrow

Texas NDN

2:13 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

That's a bit of an ASSumption about the person who passed. Being glad that ANYONE died is bad for your Karma.

Comment_arrow

Elena Conway

2:31 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

WOW!!!!!!!!!! Like like Kristine said just because they had this book doesn't mean they were Nazi. If you are still holding onto such the level of anger that you're post says about you you need to get help . at some point the anger will destroy you. I kind of feel bad for you the level of hostility from reading a very interesting article on the history of that book

Comment_arrow

Alan

3:05 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Larry Anderson - You should contact the Weisel Center, run by Elie Weisel. They have been tracking Nazis for years.. Perhaps they already know about the men you are referring to, but I think they would be the ones to contact. Also, the Holocaust Museums might be able to point you in a direction as well.

Comment_arrow

barry nicholls

3:08 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

there are so many possibilities that it seems presumptive to create the scenario you mention .And I see from the comments that you are being punished for your statements.This ia a learning moment for you

Comment_arrow

brutony

3:23 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Most Jews DID die, Kristine, because MOST "Germans" were so pre-conditioned to hate Jews, that they reported on their whereabouts, and snitched on them, to better their way of life, so they thought!

Comment_arrow

Kristine Neumann

4:39 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Cindy, did you ever think that maybe an American soldier brought it back from the war? Many soldiers brought back many things back like swords, guns, etc.

Comment_arrow

Ron Herzfeld

5:44 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Cindy,
My family, a Jewish family, living in Berlin in 1938, was urged to leave by non-Jewish German friends, some of which were German military officers. The Nazi party had a horrific agenda that many German citizens didn't condone, but were helpless to change. My aunt who was confined in three concentration camps, was helped to regain her strength by a non-Jewish German family, who became one of her best friends. Not all Germans, not nearly all, were Nazi members or supporters. They just wanted to survive and were subject to the destruction that the Nazi party brought upon them and much of Europe.

mallie

10:08 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

With WWII veterans passing away, I think you will see more of these "discoveries" as they come out of mothballs and attics - and their children have no idea of the historical significance of those little things soldiers picked up during the war. I think we will see more and more items coming to light in the next few years. Most WWII vets are over 70 or 80. My guess is that someone passed away and his children were disposing of the possessions and that was one of them - and they donated it without knowing what it was, or caring what it was.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Matthew Hendrickson

10:56 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

That's a good theory. Thanks mallie!

Comment_arrow

JB

12:21 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Considering WWII ended in '45 the age of the youngest vets is around 85... Sadly it won't be all that long until the last of them have passed on & their unwritten memories will be gone with them. I too think that we will see more of the "souvenirs" that returned home with them & have been stored away for the last 65 years. I only hope that their children & grandchildren have the sense to donate or even sell them to somebody who can & will appreciate them rather than throw something away that they don't see value in.

Comment_arrow

John Doe

12:25 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I hate to put holes in your therory, but the yougnest a WW2 veteran today would be between 85-86 years old, and most of that generation has already passed. The war was over 67 years ago and no one in their 70s would have been of age to be active militray at that time.

Comment_arrow

Arman Blenker

2:13 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

That is true many Americans went through German towns and took stamp collections, guns, and much more and brought it home in their douffle bags; that would include documents, even hand grenades and even machine guns.

Comment_arrow

brutony

3:27 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

70? The youngest WWII vet is probably 85- if you were 18 in 1945, which was the age you could first join-think of it. It could have been from a vet who recently died, and his heirs decided to leave all his war memorabilia to donations.

flow

10:30 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

It's amazing that neither of the first two institutions even caled her back. Great news that another Nazi family member died, though.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

11:01 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

Flow- How do you know it was a "Nazi Family member"? How ignorant you are. Not all Germans were Nazis, just as all Americans are not Democrats (thank God). Just as not all Americans support Obama's failure in Afghanistan, not all Germans supported Hitler's polices and failures. Wake up, Flow. Stop celebrating the possible death of someone you never knew.

Comment_arrow

Ron

11:48 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

You're absolutely right. All one hears is Nazi's all the time. Never about Mussolini, Pol Pot, Stalin, Kmer Rhouge and all the other despots.

Comment_arrow

David Davis

12:05 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Flow- How do you know it was a "Nazi Family member"? How ignorant you are. Not all Germans were Nazis, just as all Americans are not Republicans (thank God). Just as not all Americans support Bush's failure in Afghanistan, not all Germans supported Hitler's polices and failures. Wake up, Flow. Stop celebrating the possible death of someone you never knew.

Comment_arrow

1947papa

12:35 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Haha ... David the comedian. : )

Comment_arrow

godbless america

12:40 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

small minds are working here ; not just "flow" but also "billy" just had to take a strike at our president!!

Comment_arrow

Roger

12:41 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

How do you know they were German are a Nazi lots of military people bring things home with them without no one knowing.American solder could have came across that doing a rade you dont it seems we will not find out where it came from are by whom thats history for ya leave it die in the past

Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

2:11 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Dear David and godbless, we are all illustrating absurdity (of Flow) by being absurd....thanks for your contrbutions

Comment_arrow

Arman Blenker

2:31 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

You going on pure speculation and assumption. Think about it flow and I am not codeming you.
Many people think that way jumping to conclusions with out the facts. Plus people who think like would not be put on a jury and if so need to disqualify themseleves
for being prejudice.

Comment_arrow

Deborah

2:35 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I agree with the others. How can you assume it's a nazi or nazi family member. Many US military took "souvineers" from the war, which could have included this document. This could have been a member of our US military or their family member who died. Think before you speak.

Comment_arrow

brutony

3:28 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Here here-wish we could have killed more, or at least some, BEFORE WWII ever started!

Comment_arrow

sunnydays0422@aol.com

5:29 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

OK ~ so let's trace back all of the people who are related to US Soldiers who murdered Native Americans as they were moved off their land and into "reservations" and then we can be glad when they die? Or how about the people who were murdered in slave trade? Please stop making assumptions and LEARN from history, not repeat it.

Claudia

10:40 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

After the war, US SOLDIERS stayed behind to clean up. Many of them brought artifacts back home with them. That is probably where this came from, again, his children didn't know what it was, so they donated it. We have some interesting artifacts that my father in law brought back from his time in Germany. Knives, guns, books, etc

Reply

Larry Harris

10:42 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

You can't sell Nazi memorabilia on eBay. I'm glad it went to a museum where people can be reminded of humanities huge FAIL's, rather than into some neo-Nazi's sicko personal collection.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Paul Godlewski

11:57 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

Thats not quite true - just do an Ebay search under category "Militaria 1939-1945", keyword German or even nazi. Coins, Stamps, military awards, photographs, books (including original copies of Mein Kampf) are all available.

Comment_arrow

Aubree Kloes

12:14 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Are you stupid? It's not like everyone who collects Nazi memorabilia is a neo-nazi. There is such a thing as just being a WWII history buff. Yet for some reason people seem to think if you HAVE something in your house, you must therefore believe everything that that something represents. Simply not true.

Comment_arrow

Phil Sampley

12:38 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

You CAN sell Nazi memorabilia on ebay but there are a few nations where it cannot be sent to. It is better to be thought of as a fool than to open your mouth (or computer keyboard) and remove all doubt.

ruth mills

10:57 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

i know it's history many people wants to forget but it's still historical history. i'm not condoning what the nazis did to jewish people. probably who donated the book was maybe a relative from an american soldier who served during WWII or could have been a relative of a nazi soldier or maybe a german person who immagrated just after the war.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Scotty

11:50 am on Monday, August 20, 2012

In reality it's what was done to the human civilization not just "nazis did to jewish people". The world should never forget what one madman with a vengence can accomplish .

AmericanDream1

12:16 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Let's not forget what the Japanese did during WWII either. I just read "Unbroken" and was reminded again of the terrible torture in the POW camps. Why do we never talk about this any more? My guess is political correctness. We still hear about the Nazi's, but never about the Japanese.

Reply
Comment_arrow

judith

12:25 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

My father was a wwII vet, and the one thing I remember was that he never wanted to talk about it. I guess its because its never forgotten but not all try to play upon what they have been thru.

Comment_arrow

cassrole87

12:28 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

@americanDream1 the reason the japanese are not looked at as harshly, is because of the horrible things americans did to them years earlier under the first Rosevelt's presidency. need to learn some more american history before u start spreading hate

Comment_arrow

Barbara Barrow-pettard

12:38 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

you’re Right The Japanese did commit atrocities during WW2 Not only to the captured soldiers but to the different peoples where they invaded, Korea, the Philippines, & china, What they did to some of their English & Australia, Canadian, prisoners of war was atrocities, some unbelievable, however, they did not practice genocide, of a race or put forth a political ideal. But like the Nazis they thought that if you were not Japanese you were only fit for slave labor, etc. One of the only things I like about Ronald Regan was that he refused to apologize to the Japanese for the bombing of Hiroshima, and Nagasaki.
When anyone thinks we could have done different; I don’t know but the mind set at that time of the Japanese, was to die for their Emperor, to the last man woman & child and they would have attempted that I believe at the cost of more millions of American, English, Australian, Canadians and others, including so many more Japanese. That’s what happens when you have a bloated military, war machine remind you of anyone?

Comment_arrow

Larry Anderson

12:59 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

The Japanese were far more brutal and killed far more then the Germans, Chinese, Koreans, Indonesia, Vietnam, Philippines, Americans. They loved to kill, torture, rape and destroy everywhere they went. The biggest part of the German people were still humans, caught up in war but few were the homicidal maniacs as portrayed with the Nazis.

Comment_arrow

bvklaw

2:26 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

You may also want to read Clara Olink Kelly’s “The Flamboya Tree,” which describes her incarceration as a child in a Japanese POW camp in Indonesia. It mirrors my husband’s experience from age 3 to age 6. I suspect that the reason we do not talk about the atrocities committed by the Japanese is not so much a matter of political correctness as it is one of guilt over having dropped two atomic bombs on Japan.

Comment_arrow

bvklaw

2:32 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

@casserole87: AmeridanDream1 is stating a fact, which isn't spreading hate. If you haven't read "Unbroken" or "The Famboya Tree" or other accounts by former POWs of how they survived the terrible brutality of the Japanese camps in WWII, you might want to do so.

Comment_arrow

Joan Mariette Soykan

3:57 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Yes, my twin brother and I were in Japanese prison camps in Indonesia with our mom for approx. 3 years, I don't like Japanese men, but the Japanese ladies I've met have always been delightful. We should forgive and forget, that's good for us and good for the World. By the way, after WWII, I always met nice Germans when in the Netherlands, I am originally Dutch. So again we CAN'T HATE forever, therefore it's better to FORGIVE and FORGET.
J. Mariette Soykan

Comment_arrow

Tony Jacik

6:22 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Excellent point, being German myself and a WW 2 history buff I know about the Japanese camps too. Back in the 1990s a Congressman from California they called B-1 Bob Dornan spoke on the house floor and said that we should hold Japan in the same light as Nazi Germany and that every school student should know the name of the camps as easy as they know Auschwitz and Dachau. Many of the doctors that did human experiments went on to teach at universities and hospitals and then retire. Can you imagine if Dr. Mengele had taught in a university after the war and then went on to work and retire from a hospital in Berlin?

judith

12:20 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Very well said Scotty and so true.

Reply

Sheryl

12:23 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Scotty, in reality the Jewish people were the main target. Others were slaughtered also, but they wern't the target of total extermination. Now we have that Idiot in Iran trying to copy hitler if he gets a chance. The book was a great historic find and hopefully more famlies of WWII vets will look through items before disposing them. History no matter how horrific in some cases should be preserved for future generations.

Reply

Steve Yeger

12:25 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Billy Gallagher, how do you know it didn't belong to an ex-NAZI. These things pop up now. There were and still are many old Nazis living in the US who came under false pretenses. There are also many WW2 German vermacht vets in this country too that were NOT Nazis. To you disapointment. Many US soldiers who were with the European Theater victors did pick up many such "relics". I know this for a fact because I am a member of the 90th Dividion association that recovered many articles. The 90th liberated Flossenburg Concentration Camp. The camp where the top Nazi generals conspiring against Hitler were imprisoned and murdered along with Dietric Barnhoeffer, who came back to Germany to fight the Nazis pacively. You need to wake up. Stop trying to rationalize that these people could be "good guys" especially when the good guys ended up in the camps .

Reply
Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

2:04 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Sorry Steve, you are almost incoherent. No where did any one say Nazis are good guys. Saying that we didn't know that it didn't belong to an 'ex-Nazi' is asking us to prove a negative. You are saying that unless we can't prove to you that it was NOT brought over here by someone other than a Nazi, then it must have been a nazi who brought it here. Very much like Obama asking for Mitt's tax returns to 'prove' Mitt didn't 'pay zero taxes in the last 10 years'....really? Don't you think that the IRS, who reports to the Executive branch, would have been all over this the last time Mitt ran? Crazy. But, thank you for your service!

boyles1948

12:28 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

great historic find ,worth about 5K

Reply

judith

12:29 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

skeptic fence ...wonderful post exactly how I feel but couldn't get into words thank you...

Reply

1947papa

12:29 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

As Claudia said, many U.S. soldiers stayed behind to aid in the cleanup efforts, and quite probably brought mementos back home. A soldier who was age 20 in 1945, would be 87 now - and maybe he (or she) decided it was time to donate this artifact to a library to be shared with the public. In any case, it will probably remain a mystery.

Reply

barrie whitehead

12:31 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

billy gallagher,not all americans are republicans,thank god,or warmongers as george genocide bush barrie whitehead

Reply
Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

2:06 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I thought Barry was 'going to close Gitmo on day one and end the illegal war in Afganistan"...umm, never mind. Who's the warmonger now?

Joellen Hall

12:31 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I love history. We are obligated to know our history, even the dark and terrible things. How else can mankind hope to change things for the better. Those who don't know or care about history are more or less doomed to repeat the same mistakes made in the past, and only when we pay attention to the things done before us can we hope to make the world better for those who will one day read our history.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Matthew Hendrickson

2:00 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Thanks Joellen. I totally agree.

Comment_arrow

Phyllis Taylor

6:02 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

P. K. Taylor
Joellen: Thanks for your comments about knowing our history. Knowing is the only way we can possibly learn not to repeat our mistakes (hopefully). I feel sorry for the general population of Germans who were forced to be in the Nazi regime. They were so brain washed into so many lies. They were also promised a much better life if they complied with Hitler's demands which of course he reniged on. I lived in Germany for over a year while my husband was stationed there and made many German friends. They are people just like anyone else. Our land lord taught me German and I taught him English. We became good friends. He told me how the Nazi soldiers came to his home when he was a very young man and forced him to go with them to serve in their army. He at first refused but was co-erced by a bayonet to the back of his arms. He showed me the scars. Startling what can be accomplished by just a handful of people. So yes, we must know our history! My point is the German people were caught in a horrible situation with no way out. Only a handful truly wanted to be a Nazi. So sad one man could be so horrible!!!

prodeus1

12:36 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

This woman had a good heart and very little greed.She thought of others before herself.Where she could have made a lot of cash for herself but chose to GIVE this book to a place were all may view it. I'd like to think what she did was noble.Not much of that going around these days.Honest,noble,i am impressed.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Matthew Hendrickson

2:01 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I agree, prodeus1. It think that's the best part about this story. Now researchers will be able to use to the book to find out more.

Patrick Callahan

12:41 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

When I was a kid, (I'm 64 now) my friend went on a vacation to Chicago
to visit relatives. His father John Goring was my scout master in Westminster
California. He (John) was also the nephew of Herman Goring. John was by far NOT a Nazi...he retired from the US Navy and served in WWII. He obviously fought
against the Germans. As a scout master he would show us Black and White
Movies of the Holocast and explain to us how horrible the Jews were treated
by the Germans. It was obvious to us that he was ashamed of his Uncle.
But, as I remember every summer my friend's family would go back to Illinois to
visit his grandparents. Someone from the Goring family, in Illinois must have had
this book at one time or another. I have no idea who is still alive in the family living in the Illinois area. (John Goring's father was the brother of Herman Goring) The Goring family I knew in California were proud Americans.
Patrick Callahan

Reply
Comment_arrow

Marty Swinney

1:57 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Interesting coincidence. My son's girlfriend is the great neice of Herman Goering! Also, my bnext door neighbor for many years was an elderly woman who was a member of the Hitler Youth Brigade (or something like that). When I asked her about it, she told me you were either a member of the Hitler Youth or you disappeared.

Simone

12:45 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Well said Scotty. It is plain Ignorance for people to get brain washed in the hype of "all germans were nazis, all muslims are terrorists, all democrats are believers of everything obama says"....etc,etc, and continue to fuel the hatred of historical mistakes and horrors. Education does wonders to STOP the hatred and blame of a few radicals....what about what american's have done with slavery, japanese intern camps, segregation, discrimination....we have not behaved well on many occasions and often only continue to perpetuate hate by misguiding our children into believing that we are better than other cultures. I hear a lot more of americans killing, raping, terrorizing, abusing, shooting at colleges, harming our children, teaching hatred of other races, cultures, political parties, etc...than I ever hear of germans, muslims, etc going into movie theaters, or shooting up political signings...such as Gabby Giffords in AZ. We as Americans should stop selling hatred to our children and teach forgiveness and exceptance......all over the world. Maybe with education we can stop the horrors of history repeating itself. And one more thing.....I may not agree with all of Obama's policies, but if I have to choose between him and Mitt Romney who discriminates against women, I am forced to elect the lesser of 2 evils. I may have lost my job in this recession, but I am sure as hell not going to lose my birth control rights and choices.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Marty Swinney

1:23 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

A vote for "the lesser of two evils" is still a vote for evil---and no positive good can ever come from it. Just as in any mixture of food and poison, in any mnixture of good and evil only the evil can profit. "When force is the standard, the murderer wins over the pickpocket"---every time.

Comment_arrow

Marty Swinney

1:53 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I'd also like to point out that no President, Republican or otherwise, has the power to overturn Roe v. Wade, only the Supreme Court could do that. Furthermore, even if they did overturn it, it would merely revert to what it was before, namely, a state issue: each state would make its own laws on the issue, i.e., in some states it would be legal and in other states it would not be---and no one would prevent you from traveling to another state in order to get an abortion. Which kinda begs the question: just how many times (per year??) do you think you might need an abortion? I'm not trying to be facetious here, either.

Comment_arrow

prodeus1

2:16 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Simone,You won't understand this i'am sure but i found your comment so refreshing to hear the same words that go on in my head.When i have spoken the words you have written to loved one's and family members i have been asked if i'am from the u.s.s.r Because it think this way.I cant help seeing things the way thay are .Most are brain washed into believeing what ever they are told.I'am not.I have said for years education is the only answer for deprograming the masses.I told some friends the other day have we found the wepons of mass destruction yet,and one of my friends asked if i was commie! Me a commie.I was born in Chicago Ill and have a deeper love for my country then most.I just go along with Gov. lies. Killing people over oil thay won't give us is wrong.But lets go over there and get those mass distruction wepons and everys ok with this.I realy enjoyed your views and you are not alone.I feel like i just took a shower fresh in the knowlage there is life out here Thx again and hope to hear from you soon.

Hep Bantor

12:55 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

I'll bet the German museum and the Illinois museum will start returning phone calls from now on!

Reply
Comment_arrow

boyles1948

1:15 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

i agree....they missed out on very expensive item...

VED from VICTORIA INSTITUTONS

12:59 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

In a few years time, the historical enemy would identified as Great Britain. I speak thus seeing the content change in American citizenship over the last so many years.

Reply

bishopsgait

1:05 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

There are so many parallels between Nazi germany and what is going on in this country. The fawning and impotent media always warning of impending doom, the inside jobs leading to unprovoked invasions, the favoritism given to corporations and mining rights, the glorification of the military and munitions makers, the pharmaceutical growth and exotic technologies, the secret societies and infraguard, the exclusion and outright theft of certain patent and copyright holders, the obsession with nationalism (the last president) and socialism (the current prresident). Read Rise of the Fourth Reich by Jim Marrs, and understand just how the the greatest generation could not be more dishonored.

Reply

Edwin Garcia jr

1:12 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

It still shows that there tools that do not know anything and think they know everything to those folks I feel for you my wife is German and when I visited they are not proud of the time and yes not all where a hitler lovers and many,many, hide Jews !

Reply
Comment_arrow

prodeus1

1:41 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Edwin thx for the comment.I to feel that all germans are not responsable for what happened.It was the leaders of the country that should be heals accountable for the acts commited.Like now we go into a forgin country and kill many.Its not you and me its our leaders.I do'nt like war with any one.But then iam not in charge.So the people in the middle east hate all of us Americans.Even the ones not part of the war.Many germans put there lives on the line to save the jewish people from Hitler killing mechine.And for this we are all greatful.But any Nazi caught no matter how old he is should pay for his part in that war.Even if hes 103 yrs old,makes no difference.

Joyce

1:14 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Judith, My father was also in WWII. He was a medic and when he returned he didn't talk about it neither. I think he once said "It was either him or me" and won't let us know what he was thinking.

Reply
Comment_arrow

prodeus1

1:32 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Joyce,I had lost loved ones because of that war,and being jewish myself it was taught to be as soon as i could speak and understand,How much we payed with our loved ones and taught so we will never forget of forgive.We try to move foward and don't look back.But its in my heart and i can never forget.

Marty Swinney

1:15 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

A four-year economic plan for a steel factory? I guess that puts the lie to the claim that the Nazis were capitalists. Let's never forget that "Nazi" is an acronym for Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei, i.e., National SOCIALIST Workers' Party of Germany.

Reply
Comment_arrow

1947papa

2:22 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Yeow, Marty! You are obviously a well-read person. And "thank you" for reminding all these readers here what NAZI actually stands for (I didn't even know). Very scary when looking at America's current regime.

Comment_arrow

Marty Swinney

4:19 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

That yiou, 1947papa. My birth year is also 1947 and, yes, I do read quite a bit. If I may offer some further "suggested reading", you might enjioy several books by the Austrian economist, Ludwig Von Mises, notably "Planned Chaos", "Omnipotent Government" and "Socialism". For a more recent publication directly relating to your comment "Very scary when looking ar America's regime", professor of philosophy Leonard Peikoff wrote "The Ominous Parallels: The End of Freedom in America" which juxtaposes statements by various dictators (Hitler, Stalin, et.al.) with comments by person who are---shall I say?---a little closer to home. Very scary indeed!

Comment_arrow

Marty Swinney

4:21 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

PS, sorry for the typo! I meant to say "Thank you"... I should proofread my own comments a little more closely.

Amy Porfirio

1:22 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Thank you to this wonderful lady for providing yet another piece of history so that more people can understand one of the causes of this horrible murder of millions of innocent people. I don't feel we should ever forget, to forget is to allow the possibility of this happening again anywhere in the world.

Reply

taafe icyx

2:08 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

there are Americans who would have made perfect Nazi's. I won't say who they are, sadly, because they don't know that they are the ones. That is, some of you are those perfect little unquestioningly loyal little Nazi's but don't recognize it in yourselves. But here's a test: are you intolerant of other peoples' views or get angry with people who don't think, pray, look, live or speak just like you?

Reply

Barry Dennis

2:14 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

If anyone needed proof that a lack of customer service (the non-returned calls) is everyday,even for the most important things (who would know in advance?).
THink there are any red faces at the Illinmois Holocaust Museum and the German "reach out" she tried?

Reply

yannaro

2:30 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Why to a holocaust museum? The story didn't indicate it had anything to do with the Holocaust although it's possible slave labor was used at the factory. Some other options would have been the Chicago Public Library or the Library of Congress.

Reply

Andrea Clark

2:34 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

My grandfather was a German soldier who didn't agree with Hitler and was arrested and put into a concentration camp. Agreeing with everyone else, not ALL Germans agreed with Hitler or were Nazi's. He was liberated on April 29 years later that would be my birthday. I never knew my grandfather he passed away from Alzheimers but I hold my birthday as special because if he wasn't liberated I wouldn't be here. I love you Grandpa

Reply
Comment_arrow

prodeus1

3:33 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Andrea. A very special day for you to be sure.With out him you would'nt be here.Your Grand father sounds like a man of courage,and honor.who followed his heart and not his leaders.We could use some of that sprit in this country as we seem to have lost a lot of it over the years.Because of him you now live in a land of freedom what a guy ea,He gave you the gift of life and freedom.A very special man.

barry nicholls

2:59 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

billy gallagher you are a victim of fox news. It is perfectly legal to not pay taxes in this country due to loopholes tax shelters and offshoring etc. The question most of us pubs want to know is ...is it ethical and is that the kind of person we want to represent us

Reply
Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

3:19 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Really Barry? You must be joking, right? Have you ever used a mortgage deduction, or one for your kids? How about a business loss deduction, or whatever? If so, that makes you guilty of using loopholes and being of questionable ethics. Can't you see your hypocrocy???

Wanda B. Cleckler

3:06 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

My family background on both sides are GERMAN, IRISH, SWEEDEN, and ENGLISH. Also BLACK DUTCH, and SCOTTISH. But no one in my family are Nazi's even though they came from Germany.
I am glad somone was able to save that book it is our families history.

Reply

kevin reed

3:06 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

the nazi party was and is responsible for the killing and destruction of so many people. I realize that all Germans were not in the Nazi party, but to ever hold up for the nazi agenda is unforgiveable! guess if the nazis had owned that book, they would have burnt it like millions of others

Reply

lina igiel

3:29 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

i want to know why obama has not ended the 'war" ever since he came into office you dont hear boo about the war as if it is not going on. where all the war protesters now? maybe cindy sheehan is hiding behind a tree or has elected to move next door to some other unsuspecting high ranking official and harass them for a change.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mary Johnson

4:50 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Lina! I've been wondering that very same thing myself! Where IS Cindy Sheehan these days? I haven't heard a peep out of her. It saddens me to think that all of her concern for our Servicemen/women may have really just boiled down to (gasp) politics.

Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

6:32 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

When will Cindy Sheehan release her tax records? (Dems, shouldn't Harry Reid and Obama raise a ruckus over this? Never:

http://articles.cnn.com/2012-02-22/us/us_california-sheehan-taxes_1_casey-sheehan-cindy-sheehan-anti-war-activist?_s=PM:US

prodeus1

4:00 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

There is another sting that i cant wrap my head around.CHICAGO NAZI'S I grew up in the city of Chicago,and iam jewish.That aside every year the Chicago Nazi's have there march.Protected by police on either side they march in uniform, holding there flags from the 40s and bannors,slogons,bull horns blasting in an effort to recrute new members into there ranks.I know they should have the same rights as the rest of us but come on this is pushing it a little.In the past when there paths were figured out people would hide on roof tops and throw bottles and all manor of heavy objects at them.With all the Americans they have killed how can this go on it makes me weep.Thats why in the movie the blues brothers they try to run them over.Is it right for these skin heads to mass in numbers only to one day strike when there is enough of them.People hind sight is 20-20. On a positive note the only good i ever seen come out of this ,is the extra large signs of Adolf Hitler make for good targets.

Reply

brutony

4:02 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Good point, Luna- because the left doesn't mind a "Democrat" war- its the "Republican" wars they dont like!

Reply

Lila Daley

4:05 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

While troops were over takings cities and villages, they were also coming across lots of offices of high up Nazis and taking all sorts of things - guns, liquor, books, papers, pictures, and other valuables. For all we know, this book and many others was in a home of a vet who passed away. It doesn't have to be a Nazi, plus the kinds of people who would have access to a book like that in the Third Reich would be highly sought after and wouldn't keep books and other things that could possibly get them into trouble if found on them (when immigrating) or in their home.

Reply

Karen Minter

4:28 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

On behalf of the Illinois Holocaust Museum & Education Center, we are very sorry to learn that Ms. Stanek had difficulty in connecting with a Museum representative, and have reached out to her to learn more about her experience. We are committed to returning each and every phone call, and recognize the value to future generations of preserving these precious artifacts from the Nazi period. We are pleased to know that this rare artifact has found a good home at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum where it will be properly preserved. We look forward to continuing to educate both general visitors and school children about this painful chapter in history, while we salute the courage and resilience of the survivors.

Reply

Tari Marshall

4:29 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

For those who are interested, a reproduction of the book may be on display soon at the La Grange Park Library. They are working on it.

Reply

mark stuber

4:30 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

my family lived in germany during the war......my great grand father was major of that town...he was forced from office in 1933 because after the electon of hitler he refused to join the NSDAP ...if you owned a bussines or was in the wrong party you where black listed.....but maybe my grandmothers jewelry will show up on e-bay one day because there house was looted after the war ended....

Reply

lina igiel

4:33 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

i agree prodeus1, its insanity these thugs have more rights than the people they murdered, being a jew myself i dont cry but am outraged that some amercians are so fickle they would rather be politically correct and blend in with the masses than just speak truth and face the consequences because in todays world there is a price to pay should you choose to do jus
t that.

Reply

prodeus1

4:44 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

JOAN MARIETTE. This ones for you It is easy to forgive someone who steals your watch.But not some one who tried to exterminate your race thats a little bit larger then life.It would be like haveing one of your parents pour gasoline all over you set you on fire,but you didnt die,you were burned very badly and seriously disfigured for life.Now everytime you saw yourself in a mirror or your reflection in a store window you would remember who you are,what happened to you and who did it.You might not be so forgiveing after that.Thats were i am.I try to live my life al ways moveing forward.I dont hold all germans responsable for this only the leaders .Many germans were good and helpful to the jews.For that iam greatful.You may never under stand it.Even my children hold a special place in there hearts for who we are and were we come from. They learned at a very early age and it will be with them all of there lives just like me,my father,and his father befor him.

Reply

Billy Gallagher

4:49 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Dear Patch and editors: You wrote:
"Also found in between the book's pages was the letterhead of Nazi commander Hermann Göring and an envelope with a return address printed on it."
This is completely lazy reporting. You did not fact check your story it appears. That letterhead is NOT Goering's letterhead. It is from the factory/mine itself, which was named after Goering. It's like saying that you have a piece of paper that reads at the top "Aircraft Carrier Ronald Reagan" and writing a story that claims that you have a personal letterhead of Ron Reagan. OMG, please do your work if you want any respect from your readers.

Reply

Leopoldo Ainslie

4:51 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Thank you Ms. Stanek,
That book is part of our history, I lost 14 members of my family (two were Catholic Priest). Mexico gave us a secure place as we could not enter the US due to our family living in France (occupied by the German Army).
I now live in this wonderful country of ours, served 3 yers, separated with 140% total disabilities. I never questioned an order from a superior.
After the sevice in the Army, I returned to Germany to study and remained 17 more years among that gentle people, married two (not at the same time).
The only negative I have against Germany is the weather, it is not the best for my liking, Now I live in San Diego, California.
Lleo Ainslie

Reply

andrew

5:10 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

please dont tell anyone but that nazi book was mine i returned it at night as to remain anonymous. I couldnt afford the overdue charges it had been late for at least 60 years

Reply

Bea Stevens

5:43 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

My brother, a W.W.2 pilot just passed-on in Dec. and we have boxes of letters and photos - there are still veterans alive - I concur, probably brought back as a souvenir.

Reply

Unindicted Co-Conspirator

5:50 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Well, thank God I got my semi-daily Nazi or holocaust story. It's been almost 48 hours since the last story and I was getting worried that I might forget about the holocaust. After all, it was 'only' 70 years ago. (heavy sarcasm)

Reply

Tony Jacik

6:24 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Thank goodness this woman knew German, this book could have been burned. What a great piece of history, I am glad that future generations will have it to study. She sounds like a decent woman, she could have sold it for her own gain but decided to donate it to a museum.

Reply
Comment_arrow

brutony

10:05 am on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Gee, sorry, do they offend you? Are you tired of Holocaust stories, that the Jews-and others-should just forget about it already?

Tony Jacik

6:45 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Having served in our military and being a life member of the VFW, a rifleman in the Honor Guard and a patriot that it bothers me when they arrest some 95 year old man for being a Nazi. Many are arrested for working at the camps and most were enlisted men. Let me make a few points, you could not burn your draft card in Nazi Germany, the Nazi party was a political party that really only a handful of people controlled, the Nazis lied to everyone including the German people. The reason the camps were not in Germany is because they were hiding them from the German people. Most guards that were German and not Ukrainian were ones that came back from the front injured and re stationed at these camps. If there is proof that these men stabbed babies or raped women then yes go after them, but to arrest them for being a soldier and following orders is wrong. I was a soldier, there were times when you were given shot to kill orders no matter who it was, as a soldier you are not there to question your orders. Go after the officers and the men who gave the orders no the emlisted men who followed them, if you did not follow orders you and most likely your family were sent to these camps. These camps had Jewish prisoners used as trustees who help lead prisoners to their death, they did so to stay alive just like the soldiers did. The pilot of the Anola Gay that dropped the A-bomb on Japan and vaporized innocent men women and children and caused birth defects for decades were following orders

Reply

Ronald O'Donnell

5:48 am on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

I see the Passion of both sides of the discussion. But Stop-Look Around! The artifact was, if you remember, a Plan to build a Steel Mill. The above discussion has moved far from the Historical significance of the Document towards Political spin.
Everyone above agrees that the Nazi's were genocidal towards the Jews. Guilt is all around to share regardless of your ancestry, i:e; German, Jew, English, Japanese etc. I'm going to ask all of you one Question. Regardless of how the document arrived here in the U.S., What was the person trying to say with relaying the news of a plan for a Steel Mill? Before the advent of the computer, this was considered Military Intelligence. This is why the historical document is important and should be preserved. Thank you for your comments, Ronald O'Donnell

Reply

Billy Gallagher

10:22 am on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

One final thing, Patch. The book is not and has never been secret. As you stated, it was a Christmas gift given to workers at the steel facility. (please capitalize Christmas in your stories going forward)
The title translates to "Original jubilee edition to the emergence of an unusual economic region". The "Geheim" or 'secret' shown on the front cover is actually from the original blueprints for the facility. THOSE PLANS were secret, NOT this book. This book is nothing more than a commemorative collectible for the workers of the steel plant. While of interesting historical value, it is nothing significant. Kind of like finding an old picture/memory book of Electro Motive from the 40's.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ronald O'Donnell

11:50 am on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

I agree with you with one exception. The US Military was bombing the hell out of Germany at the time and Intelligence was needed at the time, as to the locations of Germany's war production facilities. No it was not the construction plans that were of interest during WWII, it was the precise location of the facility. The person bringing this information out of Germany and into the hands of our US Military should be applauded-for providing evidence of the exact location of Germany's War machine.

Your comments welcome!

Ronald O'Donnell

Comment_arrow

Billy Gallagher

1:22 pm on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

You are right, Ronald...but there is no evidence that this book was brought / smuggled out DURING the war. If it was, great. If it wasn't and brought over as a war trophy or whatever, great too.

Cindy Halpern

9:51 am on Sunday, August 26, 2012

My mother survived the Holocaust. Some of her family were murdered in Treblinka. Millions supported Hitler and the Nazis. There were righteous people who did hide Jews, but not that many.
I am sorry some of you were offended by my comments, but it is my opinion.

Reply

brutony

10:28 am on Sunday, August 26, 2012

Kudos to ur Mom, words can't describe her bravery and toughness! I hope you realize how heroic she is, and how much she sacrificed! Where was she imprisoned at? What ghetto? Did any "kindly Germans" help her? What obstacles did she encounter before AND after?

Reply

Tony Jacik

6:45 pm on Sunday, August 26, 2012

Yes Cindy many did support Hitler but they did not know about the death camps. That fact was kept secret from the German people because the Nazis knew they would not stand for it or agree with it, that is why all the camps were outside of Germany. The one camp in Germany was used to for homosexuals, political prisoners and Hitler's opposition, the German people were told the Jewish people were being relocated, neither the German people or the Jewish people knew they were going to death camps. In most camps the Nazis used Ukranian guards because of their brutality and all camps used Jewish trustees that helped the Nazis send people to their death. Once word started coming back about the camps it was too hard to believe and if you were a guard or a Jewish prisoner you did what you were told or you might be next. It was a sad part of history and ruthless dictators like Stalin {who murdered more people than Hitler} Pol Pot, Idi Amin, Hitler, Saddam Hussien all brutally murdered millions of innocent people. We need to remember these men and learn from them so we do not allow another one to come to power.

Reply

brutony

10:18 pm on Sunday, August 26, 2012

Didn't you write this rant b4 on here, Tony?

Reply

Tony Jacik

12:17 pm on Monday, August 27, 2012

Rant? LOL, not sure how you could call it a rant. Trying to keep fresh how brutal dictators hurt humanity and effect citizens and the lives of innocent people. More of a fact check of how an evil person can come to power, take over and bring out the bad in humans. More of a "don't let history repeat itself" but as you can see the men I mention are from the 1930s to the when we took out Saddam, does not look like we learn much from human suffering. Plus the things still going on today, slave trades, sex slaves, wars, hunger, female mutulations, etc. looks like we will have more evil dictators and more ethnic cleansing in our future.

Reply

brutony

3:03 pm on Monday, August 27, 2012

I meant to say you've written that same piece earlier, didn't u? Didn't mean to imply that it wasn't relevant, or correct, which it was.

Reply

Sonia Guzman

11:12 am on Tuesday, September 18, 2012

I have recently found out that some of my family lived in a secret German society in Argentina and they later moved to the islands in the Caribbean. The thought that they were in any way involved in the Holocaust is frightening and shameful to me.

Reply

Tony Jacik

12:56 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012

It should be Sonia but odds are unless your family member was a high ranking official they had little or no knowledge of the holocaust until it was too late or after the war. Nazi propoganda minister Joseph Goebbels controlled what the German people could see, read or hear in the news and he did a good job with it. I have relatives that fought for Germany and America and I had an uncle who was SS that died in Russia, my wife has an uncle who was captured by the Russians and thought to be killed, he showed up at their door in 1956 eleven years after the war was over. All sides were supposed to release any prisoners after the war but Russia used millions as slave labor and many died for nothing which is a crime in itself. The holocaust was top secret and only a handful of top Nazis were aware of what they were actually doing which is why the camps were outside of Germany and they used Ukranians as guards not Germans. It was a dark part of history for mankind and we should never forget the atrocities committed by all sides but what the Nazis did was far worse than the other countries. Hitler and Stalin were the most brutal dictators the world has ever seen, between them they are estimated to have killed over 100 million people. You would think man would learn but since Stalin and Hitler there has been pol pot, Idi Amin, Saddam Hussien, Slobodan Milosevic, chairman Mao..I guess mankind did not learn their lesson after the holocaust which is the real shame...

Reply

Sonia Guzman

1:14 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012

I always heard about how Nazis found refuge in Argentina. So when we found out that our family lived in that German community and changed their name from Gutzmann to the more Spanish sounding name of Guzman, there has been a lot of speculation among our family members. I know that they were business men and probably found it easier to use a Spanish sounding name in place of German spelling of our name.

Reply

brutony

1:59 pm on Tuesday, September 18, 2012

They're probably just Germans who didn't want to be associated with Nazis!

Reply

Cindy Halpern

3:19 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012

I looked at all the comments and some of you can not understand how my mother and her family endured the Holocaust. Some of my family perished.
But some of you don't appreciate the awful suffering caused by the Nazis. You are the ones who need an education. The local Holocaust Museum in Glen Cove is the perfect place to start that education.

Reply

Cindy Halpern

12:19 pm on Friday, November 9, 2012

It is very sad for me that my mother, who survived the Holocaust, is reaching the end of her days. Of course, I shall miss her, but I am worried that there are very few people left who can give an eyewitness account.
These comments relating to what I original wrote worry me. People forget easily what the Nazis and actually blame me, as the daughter of a survivor, for my anger, saying I need help.
I will never forgive or forget what the Nazis did.

Reply

Tony Jacik

12:37 pm on Wednesday, November 28, 2012

I understand what you are saying Cindy, you are right people do tend to forget. I do not think the education system teaches about the holocaust they way it did when we were in school. There will always be memorials and museums to ensure that people never forget but the people have to make that effort to go there. What I find sad is that since the holocaust there have been many other accounts of ethnic cleansing and genocide. Even shortly after the Nazi holocaust Josef Stalin continued to persecute the Jewish population and others, then in the 1970s Khmer Rouge leader Pol Pot and Uganda president Idi Amin had their own holocaust. In the 1990s Slobodan Milosevic in Bosnia was guilty of another holocaust with his genocide and gendercide. Saddam Hussien gassed and murdered millions and the human atrocities and the forced sex slave trade going on in Rwanda for the last 30 years. I wish I could say mankind did learn something from the Nazi holocaust but sadly there will always be another Stalin, Hitler, Amin or Hussien waiting to come to power. I think if more people were taught about these atrocities it would help but sadly many kids today cannot tell you or even name any of these countries even the most famous one with the Nazis, I wish more schools would teach the children about all these holocausts because there is always a face there, like your mother they do have families and it is harder to ignore when they can put a face to it, it becomes more personal.

Reply

Cindy Halpern

2:26 pm on Saturday, April 13, 2013

Rest in peace, Mom, who was a Holocaust Survivor.
September 16, 1921 to April 9, 2013.
Love, Your daughter,
Cindy Halpern

Reply

brutony

3:02 pm on Saturday, April 13, 2013

Ditto. Cindy, my condolences!

Reply

Leave a comment